Exercise is great for improving your health and ultimately your life, but you may not be reaping all of the benefits exercise provides if you’re not eating a healthy, balanced diet. The old adage “You can’t outrun a bad diet” may have more merit than you realize.
In this article, we’ll go over how it might be a bad idea for not only your fitness goals, but your health, to try to overcome bad eating habits with exercise.
The Misconception That Exercise Can Cancel Out Bad Eating
Most people understand that exercising is great for your body and your health. Lots of people even know that exercise can help you lose weight. The problem here is that there is a misunderstanding of how much of an impact exercise has on weight in combination with your diet.
There’s a common belief that “as long as you exercise, you don’t have to worry about your diet as much”. This couldn’t be further from the truth.
The way you eat plays a big role in your weight endeavor and your overall health and fitness. Think about putting unleaded gas into your car when it’s designed for premium fuel. It may run but it won’t run well. The performance drops, efficiency tanks, and over time, you risk serious damage.
Loads of people use their workouts as an excuse to eat fast food or junk foods as their post-workout meal. Over time, this unhealthy habit turns into a justification cycle.
If you’re not going down the junk food justification drain (say that 5 times fast), you may likely be using exercise as a punishment for your poor eating habits. Many beginners tend to punish themselves or use exercise as a “tool” to ease the bad meals that they’ve eaten.
But again, it doesn’t work like that. It’s not that easy. And it gets much worse if you combine the cyclical justification of junk food and exercising as self punishment for eating bad meals. The two habits combined can quickly turn into a vicious self defeating cycle.
This cycle ultimately sets you up with a toxic relationship with food and fitness. This will lead you to spinning your wheels towards plateaus and even stalling out. Or in other words: working hard, but getting nowhere.
[RELATED: The Secret to Long-Term Success: How to Master Moderation with Food Without Feeling Deprived]
Calorie Burn from Exercise Is Surprisingly Low
You’d be surprised to know how many calories exercise actually burns. An hour of hard cardio may burn about 400 to 500 calories! My best guess is that people find it easy to overestimate their calorie burn based on the effort they exert during their workouts.
With no idea how calorie burning works, coming out of the gym huffing and puffing, clothes drenched in sweat, tired and exhausted, you’d think you just burned a day’s worth of energy. But heavy breathing, sweating, and feeling tired have very little to do with actual calorie burn.
Heavy breathing has more to do with how efficient your cardiovascular system is. Sweating is simply the body’s system to cool your body temperature. And feeling tired can have a whole host of reasons like poor sleep, not enough food before exercise, stress, and who knows what else.
However, what we do know is that exercise doesn’t burn a whole lot of calories like we’d like it to.
In fact, one fast food meal can wipe out your entire workout’s worth of calories (or beyond!). Don’t be one of the ones who overestimate their calories burned and underestimate their calories eaten.
High-calorie, tasty foods—like fast food, junk food, and other bad options we may rationalize eating after a workout— are very easy to over consume and can make your fitness goals harder to obtain.
Daily movement is critical for your health, but it’s not the silver bullet for fat loss and overall health. It’s merely a piece of the bigger puzzle.
Nutrition Impacts More Than Just Weight
Now that you understand how poor food choices can cause you to eat more calories than you’d like, you’ll want to avoid being short-sighted with your diet.
You may be thinking that you’ll just eat smaller amounts of junk to offset the higher collection of calories you used to eat. I admire your creativity, but this thought process is flawed.
A poor diet affects more than just your calorie count. Your food choices affect your sleep, mood, energy levels, focus, hormones, and more—even if you workout.
Eating high-sugar, processed foods will lead to blood sugar spikes, energy crashes, and intense cravings. Not to mention that this cycle tends to feed itself. Meaning, you’ll be wanting more processed foods and you’ll end up repeating this habit over and over again.
Diet quality also influences recovery, muscle growth, and inflammation. Eating clean will properly fuel your workouts while junk food can slow you down or hold you back.
Exercise also cannot undo any nutrient deficiencies. If you’re not getting enough Vitamin D, Magnesium, Iron, etc., you’ll never be able to make that up through exercise. You have to actually eat something in order for your body to process the nutrients.
Fitness isn’t just about being lean and muscular or athletic—it’s about how your body feels and functions and improving your quality of life.
It’s Hard to Outrun A Bad Diet, But You Can Certainly Out-Eat Any Workout Plan
Since we’ve already discussed how little exercise actually burns, let’s think about how easy it is to consume calories.
It’s shockingly easy to eat back (or overeat) all of your hard work. If you burned 300 calories by jumping rope for 20 minutes straight, you would still be a few calories short of burning off just 1 cheeseburger. Not to mention that I didn’t even say anything about including fries and a drink.
Let that thought digest for a minute.
This also goes south fast for those who emotionally eat, stress eat, or eat out of boredom. All of these calories still count and add up quickly. One family sized bag of chips could offset your entire workout.
This is why you see athletes operating within a structured environment, even athletes can gain fat despite their high activity if they’re not careful. So how would you think the average person would fare against poor food choices?
Long-term progress demands food and drink awareness, not just gym dedication alone. The results come faster when diet and exercise work together, not against each other.
You can’t build your physique or improve your health on junk fuel. Your discipline in the kitchen matters just as much as your exercise.
The Verdict: Can You Outrun A Bad Diet?
Well actually, yes.
But should you?
No, because it’s a terrible idea.
It is possible to burn more calories than you consume from bad food choices through sheer exercise, but it requires an extreme amount of daily activity.
You may think that you’re up for the task, but I’m telling you you’re not. The amount of activity you’d need would be marathon level (depending on how bad you eat, of course).
One high calorie meal may be around 1,200 calories, that alone may cost you 2+ hours of running to burn off. Mind you, this is only for one meal. Think about if you at like trash all day.
So, let’s say you can put forth hours of hard exercise every day to make up for the junk food. Do you think hours upon hours of exercise is sustainable for weeks, months, and years on end?
We already talked about how junk food leads to poor recovery, energy crashes, and increased cravings—even if you’re burning all the calories. With poor recovery, don’t you think at some point you’ll be fatigued or risking injury?
You can’t make any progress when you’re injured because injuries require rest in order for you to heal.
In addition to this entire mess, your long-term health will suffer. Exercise can’t undo high blood pressure, inflammation, or insulin resistance from all the processed foods you want to eat.
This goes back to my unleaded fuel in the premium fuel car analogy from before. Driving your car faster or for longer distances won’t help the unleaded gas make your car operate better. If anything, it exacerbates the problem. That’s exactly what happens when you try to outrun a bad diet.
Key Takeaways: Why You Can’t Outrun a Bad Diet
You can technically burn off junk food with enough exercise — but that doesn’t mean you should. It’s inefficient, unsustainable, and damaging to your health in the long run.
- Exercise burns fewer calories than most people think. One tough workout won’t cancel out a high-calorie day.
- Junk food affects more than weight — it impacts recovery, mood, cravings, hormones, and overall health.
- You can easily eat back everything you burned (and more) with just one processed meal or snack.
- Using workouts to justify poor eating or punish yourself creates a toxic cycle that leads to burnout and plateaus.
- Even if you could “outrun” your diet today, the physical and mental cost stacks up fast — eventually, your body will push back.
Your health, physique, and fitness all benefit when you treat food like fuel and not something to undo. Focus on eating well most of the time — your workouts will feel better, your results will come faster, and your body will thank you for it.
Have you ever caught yourself trying to “earn” your meals with exercise? Or used a tough workout to justify eating something you knew would set you back?
Drop a comment below — I’d love to hear your thoughts or your own experiences with this cycle. And if this helped shift your mindset even a little, share this with someone who you think is trying to outrun a bad diet or needs to hear this too.
In need of a Printable Exercise Tracker Because You’re Struggling to Stay Consistent?
Build better fitness habits with The Keys to Fitness: Weekly Habit Tracker! Download it for FREE and start tracking your progress today. Stay accountable, stay on track, and make fitness a lasting habit!
Share this article!
Follow us on Social Media!
